so i just finished a Sheralyn Kenyon book, Born of Night (i think i spelt her name wrong but i'm too lazy to look it up) and i was glued to it like the cheezy supernatural romance fan that i am. but in my defense i can honestly say that her stories have merit in that they do not take themselves too seriously.
still i was surprised how much i was into this book especially since there was some very over the top cliche writing and plot twists. but i keep thinking about the story because 1 - the main male character really struck me at first and 2 - i hated the ending.
what i loved was the violence and cruelty that the main character had under gone in his past. sure, the author does a lot of "tell", but as the book went on because it was mentioned so often, seen in his memories and from the eyes of those around him, it hit you like "show". and i was surprised at how violent the author wrote his past - actually mentioning him as a child being raped by child predators on the command of his father - which is just one of the hardships he had undergone - i thought was a little much for this type of novel. and i was impressed by it. usually it just makes reference to this sort of thing, or there was physical abuse or some sort of betrayal or incident, but Kenyon tells it deeper than that. true, there was no play by play and she doesn't show any violent sexual scenes, but still i was impressed with how far she went.
then i was utterly disappointed that true to romance form, the addition of the female leads "makes everything better". bullshit. a man that suffered what Nykyrian suffered would not be soothed by a woman, least of all one named Kiara *gag*. sure Nykyrian may be cheesy too, but i really abhor overly girlie names, or swirly names as i call them, because the short vowels swirl up and down when you say it and you can just imagine lots of curly-qs when she writes it too. it just makes me think of instant wide eyed helpless but strong in spirit princess. or tough as nails but still utterly gorgeous tom boy. get real.
ok maybe i was a bit harsh there on the girl name, but the "change of heart hero" - please. i know that the Romance genre is littered with them, i mean i guess that is why women read this stuff, the whole savior complex. and maybe sometimes it doesn't bother me, maybe sometimes i like it. but not right now. now i am just jaded and disillusioned.
now i don't want the hero to have a total change of heart. i want the hero to still be broken. the case with Nykyrian for instance: anyone who went through what the author described would not have been healed so quickly or thoroughly by finding love. no way no how. yes he might love. yes he might let someone into himself - but it would not be all relief and roses. it was be painful and i imagine there would be false starts and set backs. he would be a very difficult person to stay with maybe. and i just don't see our heroine, most heroines, as the kind to do that. there is always that point in the plot where the heroine is deceived, thus turning her back on the noble savage and forsaking everything she just told him about her love for him. i understand this is a plot mechanic to keep the tension going, but there has to be a better way. i totally wouldn't take back someone who so quickly changed their mind about me, even with good reason. ok, so maybe i don't know what i would do personally, but story wise - i just think that heroines could be made of stronger less catty stuff.
i would have loved, LOVED this novel if the hero had stayed stayed tormented, or if she had shown that he would still be tormented and needed to adjust to having someone in his life. also if the reversal of fortune hadn't happened in regards to his family, his true family. i thought the "surprise i'm really someone you would never have thought" was a bit much on top of the "my life was shit but now it's ok because you're here".
anyway, i am hungrily making my way through the second novel in the series. it is pretty much the same writing, but i am more pleased with the heroine so far - she is the tough as nails yet still gorgeous kind - but she isn't afraid of laughing at herself or being humble. this is a story of betrayal and probably forgiveness and i of course would rather see him shoot her than forgive her, but then i suppose it wouldn't be romance now would it?
still i was surprised how much i was into this book especially since there was some very over the top cliche writing and plot twists. but i keep thinking about the story because 1 - the main male character really struck me at first and 2 - i hated the ending.
what i loved was the violence and cruelty that the main character had under gone in his past. sure, the author does a lot of "tell", but as the book went on because it was mentioned so often, seen in his memories and from the eyes of those around him, it hit you like "show". and i was surprised at how violent the author wrote his past - actually mentioning him as a child being raped by child predators on the command of his father - which is just one of the hardships he had undergone - i thought was a little much for this type of novel. and i was impressed by it. usually it just makes reference to this sort of thing, or there was physical abuse or some sort of betrayal or incident, but Kenyon tells it deeper than that. true, there was no play by play and she doesn't show any violent sexual scenes, but still i was impressed with how far she went.
then i was utterly disappointed that true to romance form, the addition of the female leads "makes everything better". bullshit. a man that suffered what Nykyrian suffered would not be soothed by a woman, least of all one named Kiara *gag*. sure Nykyrian may be cheesy too, but i really abhor overly girlie names, or swirly names as i call them, because the short vowels swirl up and down when you say it and you can just imagine lots of curly-qs when she writes it too. it just makes me think of instant wide eyed helpless but strong in spirit princess. or tough as nails but still utterly gorgeous tom boy. get real.
ok maybe i was a bit harsh there on the girl name, but the "change of heart hero" - please. i know that the Romance genre is littered with them, i mean i guess that is why women read this stuff, the whole savior complex. and maybe sometimes it doesn't bother me, maybe sometimes i like it. but not right now. now i am just jaded and disillusioned.
now i don't want the hero to have a total change of heart. i want the hero to still be broken. the case with Nykyrian for instance: anyone who went through what the author described would not have been healed so quickly or thoroughly by finding love. no way no how. yes he might love. yes he might let someone into himself - but it would not be all relief and roses. it was be painful and i imagine there would be false starts and set backs. he would be a very difficult person to stay with maybe. and i just don't see our heroine, most heroines, as the kind to do that. there is always that point in the plot where the heroine is deceived, thus turning her back on the noble savage and forsaking everything she just told him about her love for him. i understand this is a plot mechanic to keep the tension going, but there has to be a better way. i totally wouldn't take back someone who so quickly changed their mind about me, even with good reason. ok, so maybe i don't know what i would do personally, but story wise - i just think that heroines could be made of stronger less catty stuff.
i would have loved, LOVED this novel if the hero had stayed stayed tormented, or if she had shown that he would still be tormented and needed to adjust to having someone in his life. also if the reversal of fortune hadn't happened in regards to his family, his true family. i thought the "surprise i'm really someone you would never have thought" was a bit much on top of the "my life was shit but now it's ok because you're here".
anyway, i am hungrily making my way through the second novel in the series. it is pretty much the same writing, but i am more pleased with the heroine so far - she is the tough as nails yet still gorgeous kind - but she isn't afraid of laughing at herself or being humble. this is a story of betrayal and probably forgiveness and i of course would rather see him shoot her than forgive her, but then i suppose it wouldn't be romance now would it?
Current Mood:
aggravated
1 comment | Leave a comment
